100% Authenticity Guarantee
Buy with confidence. Every autograph we sell is professionally authenticated, sealed with a tamper-evident hologram, paired with a matching Certificate of Authenticity (COA), and traceable via online serial lookup — backed by the most trusted names in the industry.
Why Authenticity Matters
The value of sports memorabilia begins with trust. That’s why we partner only with reputable authenticators and attach a unique, traceable identity to each autograph we sell.
- ✓ Professional third-party review and certification
- ✓ Serialized hologram on the item
- ✓ Matching Certificate of Authenticity (COA)
- ✓ 24/7 online lookup by serial number
- ✓ Clear returns process for disputed items
- ✓ Lifetime confidence for your collection
How It Works
| Step | What We Do | What You Get |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Professional Authentication | Certified by PSA/DNA, JSA, Beckett, or Fanatics. | Independent verification from industry leaders. |
| 2. Serialized Hologram | Tamper-evident hologram with a unique serial. | Permanent physical marker tied to your item. |
| 3. Matching COA | Certificate with matching serial ID. | Official proof of authenticity. |
| 4. Online Verification | Serials are registered for instant lookup. | 24/7 confirmation — anytime, anywhere. |
Verify Your Item
Find the hologram or COA number, then choose your authenticator:
Our Promise
If any autographed item you purchase from us is ever found inauthentic by a leading third-party authenticator, we’ll refund your purchase price in full. Period.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you sell items without a COA?
We strive to offer only items with a serialized hologram and matching COA. If an item uses a different verification method (e.g., Fanatics Hologram), it will be noted on the product page with "This item is guaranteed to pass any third party authentication company including Beckett, PSA/DNA, & JSA authentication."
What if I lose my COA?
You can still verify the item using the hologram. If both are missing, contact us with your order # and photos so we can help.
Can I re-verify years later?
Yes. The serial lookup remains available with the authenticator indefinitely.
Are unsigned products covered?
This guarantee specifically covers autographed items. Non-autographed products follow our standard return policy.
Questions? We’re Here to Help.
Email: orders@gamedaysportsmemorabilia.com
Phone: +1 (844) 747-1658